Teen Mexican Illegal with TB in Atllanta

Forums Home | The FireWire | Breaking News

Posts 1-9 of 9 | Latest Post
August 26, 2007 09:55 PM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
February 16, 2007
Teen jailed for TB denied having disease, officials say


The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 08/25/07

When doctors told Francisco Santos he had tuberculosis Friday, health officials said the Gwinnett County 17-year-old refused to believe it.

Then the wiry, dark-haired youth refused to submit to any treatment. Worse, he said he was walking out of the Gwinnett Medical Center in Lawrenceville and heading back to his home country of Mexico, officials said.

Francisco Santos lives in Norcross with at least one parent and several younger siblings, records show.
 

"I think he was scared," said David Will, attorney for the Gwinnett County Board of Health.

Gwinnett health officials found themselves in a bind. They had a person with a case of active, contagious tuberculosis, refusing treatment and threatening to carry the disease to a foreign country.

They also were aware of the recent incident involving Atlanta lawyer Andrew Speaker, who also has tuberculosis. After Speaker left for his wedding in Greece, a national news conference set off an international health scare.

In this case, the Gwinnett officials acted decisively: They put Santos in jail Friday evening, in a rare act of a government agency confining a sick person. Santos is the only inmate in a special medical isolation cell designed for inmates with contagious conditions. The cell, which measures about 15 feet by 20 feet, has a special ventilation system that keeps the air from reaching other inmates.

The 5-foot-5 teenager has a toilet, sink, bed and a mirror made of polished metal. Two deputies guard him and the other medical inmates.

Will, the county health attorney, said Santos was detained because he is a public health threat.

"He has active, contagious TB," Will said Saturday. "He is at risk of communicating that with anybody he comes in contact with."

Will said Santos is being held under a court order for confinement. He'll stay in that cell until either he starts cooperating and accepting treatment, or a judge makes some other decision at a Sept. 5 hearing. At that commitment hearing, the judge could decide to place him in a hospital with security.

Looking for recent contacts
Meanwhile, Gwinnett health officials have started tracking down those people Santos may have come in contact with, such as family members. Will said Santos, who lists his address in jail records as Norcross, lives with at least one parent and several younger siblings. His jail records also indicate he is unemployed.

Santos listed his birth place as Mexico. Will said he did not know the status of Santos' citizenship. The Gwinnett jail has two federal immigration agents who screen foreign-born inmates to determine whether to investigate their status and potentially place a hold on them for deportation.

As early as Monday, Gwinnett health officials expect to speak publicly about the extent of Santos' disease and his treatment.

Right now, it remains unclear how long his confinement may go on. If he starts cooperating and obtaining treatment, he could be moved to a hospital and, when he is no longer contagious, sent home for further treatment. But if he continues his denials, the judge may commit him to a hospital with security for treatment, Will said.

Speaker case drew attention
His case arrives only about a month after Speaker, the Atlanta attorney, was released from hospital isolation in Denver. When the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention interrupted his honeymoon in Greece, Speaker and his bride raced back to the United States to avoid detention in Italy.

Once back in the U.S., Speaker spent time under armed guard at Grady Memorial Hospital — the first person placed under a federal isolation order in more than 40 years. Speaker's case drew heightened concern because he was diagnosed with a particularly drug-resistant form of tuberculosis.

Will he did not know the extent of Santos' disease.

Speaker, commenting on the Santos case, said that if indeed the testing was accurate on Santos being contagious, then the Gwinnett officials acted appropriately.

"It's in the public's interest that he be forced to seek treatment," Speaker said Saturday.

At the same time, Speaker stressed that his case was different. When he left the country, Speaker said Fulton County health officials had said he was not contagious and not a threat to anyone. Fulton County health officials, however, have contended they clearly "advised" Speaker not to travel, and they have since been criticized for failing to sequester Speaker before he departed the country.

In the Santos case, custody was sought by the Gwinnett County health department through a petition for commitment. Such petitions are "extremely rare," Will said. "I personally have not been involved in one in more than a decade," he said.

In his isolation cell, Santos is alert and walking around, officials said. He does not have the appearance of a sickly person and has not been a problem for jail officials, apart from his unwillingness to accept treatment, officials said.

The Gwinnett officials hope his family members talk some sense into the headstrong youth.

"Everybody's hoping he will undergo the treatment," Will said.

August 26, 2007 10:12 PM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
March 3, 2007

My microbiology Professor was just talking about TB  and Andrew Speaker last thursday during lecture. He said it was a good thing Speaker did not have XDR TB strain (extra drug resistant- meaning: a lot of our antibiotics are useless). TB takes so long to culture in the lab. The CDC isn't going to let this kid go anywhere if he is currently in a "contagious" state and probably will be for some time, the antibiotic regimen is massive and treatment lasts for very many years. We will probably be seeing a lot more of that as 3rd world countries do not vaccinate or monitor their populations for TB. A lot of the XDR strains of TB originated in the Soviet Union Prisons as inmates spread it to entire populations, were not given full regimens or appropriate antibiotics- so TB acquired antibiotic immunity on its own....that my friends is what we call co-evolution. An ancient bacteria that has been around since the beginning of time finds a way to further its survival and strike down mans quest to erradicate the disease altogether.

Excellent post a12iggymom and yet another reason we need to secure our borders. Legal Immigrants go through health screening, blood test...etc to be sure they are not carriers of exotic or contagious disease. If you refer to the monthly CDC morbidity and mortality rate for the United States, it will show a few diseases brought here from 3rd world countries that the US has vaccinated its population for: Diptheria is one that comes to mind and whooping cough is making a comeback....we have the DPT vaccination our children receive which is VERY effective. (Diptheria, Pertussis, Tetanus)=DPT

  




"I have wondered at times what the Ten Commandments would have looked like if Moses had run them through the US Congress." Ronald Reagan "Evil is powerless when the good are unafraid." Ronald Reagan
August 26, 2007 10:33 PM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
February 5, 2007
Why did the government not put all HIV positive and aids infected persons in medical camps like the leprosy camps of years gone by. Just think how many lives would have been saved by that action alone. Put this guy in a isolation van and transport him back to Mexico and let his government take care of him.


TEXAS: One of the few states that can secede from the Union.
August 26, 2007 10:40 PM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
February 14, 2007
Buttt----This is not the first case , just another one . I limit my anxiety disorder prompted addiction to gambling and don't visit the casinos much any more , going only on slow non-peak periods for this reason . Being in the public , ANYWHERE is not the best idea , and I don't laugh  at those who go around wearing those white surgery masks anymore . ( not out loud anyway )


Vote Responsibly and if you don't vote don't complain around me .
August 27, 2007 10:25 AM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
March 3, 2007
blaze77535 said: Why did the government not put all HIV positive and aids infected persons in medical camps like the leprosy camps of years gone by. Just think how many lives would have been saved by that action alone. Put this guy in a isolation van and transport him back to Mexico and let his government take care of him.

 

Blaze7735...it is easy to say "ship him back"...but if you do and he does NOT receive proper treatment or is denied the proper regimen of antibiotics for the appropriate amount of time...this WILL spread among the mexican population AND it could become a stronger strain that is harder to kill because it was not dealt with properly in the first place...you really want to trust Mexican healthcare system to "take care of the problem"? 

You can't put HIV positive people in isolation as the only way their disease is spread is through...well you know....S*X...

There is or used to  be a leper colony in Louisiana.




"I have wondered at times what the Ten Commandments would have looked like if Moses had run them through the US Congress." Ronald Reagan "Evil is powerless when the good are unafraid." Ronald Reagan
August 27, 2007 10:44 AM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
February 14, 2007
blaze77535 said: Why did the government not put all HIV positive and aids infected persons in medical camps like the leprosy camps of years gone by. Just think how many lives would have been saved by that action alone. Put this guy in a isolation van and transport him back to Mexico and let his government take care of him.

 

             The Mexican government would just take him to another isolated stretch of our border and let him out.

                 You are dead on BiotechBabe; this is a prime example of the need for real border security. Unscreened illegals working in food service, hotels, etc are putting the American public at risk. Enough is enough. Somebody needs to start taking this seriously.




Alabama born and bred. Where we "Dare Defend our Rights!"
August 27, 2007 10:51 AM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
February 5, 2007
BTB he is not the only case of TB to come from Mexico and there are a lot more in Mexico. They have clinics in Mexico


TEXAS: One of the few states that can secede from the Union.
August 27, 2007 02:23 PM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
March 3, 2007
blaze77535 said: BTB he is not the only case of TB to come from Mexico and there are a lot more in Mexico. They have clinics in Mexico

 

I KNOW that Blaze...I  studied Infectious Disease on the Pre Med level last semester and have studied Microbiology for the past 4 years. Jason knows what I am talking about with the possibility of causing a pandemic in this country by the spread of a disease that defies treatment. We have had quite a few come in from the soviet union too....their strain of TB carries multiple resistance to antibiotics. There are simply too many "unscreened illegals", some want to outright kill us...but these people could kill us and it wouldn't even be intentional because they are simply "carriers" of an infectious agent that easily spreads from person to person and they may not exhibit any of the "classic" symptoms associated with that disease. We would have NO IDEA unless we screened them prior entry into our country.

If you go to Australia and I know many of you who have traveled there know what I am talking about...you are often "sprayed" before being allowed out of the airport to be sure you do not bring in any microbes or insects or whatever that is not indigenous to their continent and may infect their local species of plants and/or animals.




"I have wondered at times what the Ten Commandments would have looked like if Moses had run them through the US Congress." Ronald Reagan "Evil is powerless when the good are unafraid." Ronald Reagan
August 27, 2007 02:37 PM    View printable version     Link to this comment   
Member Since:
February 23, 2007
There are many diseases, Americans thought to be under control, and not a problem coming back into America. Our community hospital has had cases of whooping cough, TB, and others. This is one reason to have controlled Immigration. Our Founding Fathers were not ignorant.


"It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so." Mark Twain

You must login to discuss this item.